DashStash vs Buttondown

At 4,000 subscribers DashStash is $18 a month against Buttondown’s $29, and every feature is included, so there are no add-ons to buy.

DashStash costs less at 3 of 5 list sizes Buttondown quotes on request at 100,000
Coming from Buttondown?
83%less than Buttondown
List size4,000 subscribers
DashStashStarter$18a month
ButtondownLite$109a month
You save $91a month

The cheapest plan for the list, at one email a week, billed monthly in US dollars. Buttondown prices taken from buttondown.com/pricing, October 2026.

Head to head

Point by point.

Where DashStash does more, where Buttondown does more, and where the two are even. A dash means we did not check that item for that product.

Feature DashStash Buttondown
AI campaign ideas
Finds customers ready to return and drafts the email. You approve it.Ahead
—
Product suggestions
Chosen for each customer from their past orders.Ahead
—
Works with your store
Shopify, Square, WooCommerce, Stripe and QuickBooks plug in.Ahead
—
Tap-to-answer blocks in emails
Polls, reviews, bookings and buy links readers use inside the email.
Comments and surveys, sold as a $9 a month add-on.
Auto emails
Moments and flows for welcome, win-back and reorder.Ahead
An add-on at $29 a month.
Writing tools
Block editor, with slash commands and AI rewrites.
A rich text editor or Markdown.
What you get
Every plan has every feature.Ahead
Extras like tagging, automations and paid subscriptions are sold as add-ons, from $9 to $79 a month.
Charging subscribers
Not included.
An add-on at $9 a month.Ahead
Free tier
None. Prices begin at $18 a month.
No charge for the first 100 subscribers.Ahead
What you pay each month

The gap grows as you grow.

The cheapest plan for each list size at one email a week. Hover over a point or tap a card below.

At 100,000 subscribers Buttondown quotes on request, and its extras are billed as add-ons on top of these prices. DashStash charges by emails sent, at about four emails a subscriber a month.

Finding your fit

Plain advice.

Choose Buttondown if…

  • You want a tidy writing tool that handles Markdown, and you like paying only for the extras you use.
  • Your list is small, and at 1,000 subscribers Buttondown costs less than DashStash.
  • You want paid subscriptions as an inexpensive add-on.

Choose DashStash if…

  • You sell products or services and want people who bought before to return.
  • You want automations, recommendations and interactive blocks in the price, not as add-ons to add up.
  • You want the smallest bill as your list grows: DashStash is $149 a month at 50,000 subscribers against $319 on Buttondown.
Coming from Buttondown?

Your list comes with you.

  1. 1
    Get your subscribers out

    Save your subscriber list from Buttondown as a CSV file.

  2. 2
    Bring it into DashStash

    DashStash lines up the columns and skips anyone who unsubscribed or bounced.

  3. 3
    Sign off one campaign

    DashStash writes a first welcome-back note from your customer history. Read it, then hit send.

buttondown-subscribers.csv4,000 rows
→DashStash
Waiting for your file0
3,888people brought in
112unsubscribed or bounced, skipped

A demo with sample numbers.

Start when you like

Draft it once. Send it right.

Put it together from blocks and view it on a phone. Pick your send time, then see who opened it. Bring your list over and send from your own domain.

Take a look inside